Hodman, I do not disagree, competition as a compliment to training go's hand in hand. Now like imperfect training makes imperfect scores or bad habits. I would first say, "what do you want out of competition?" If you want to compliment your training, then do as you were taught, if it is legal in that sport, use the firearm you want to be great with, and use the techniques you were taught if legal. If your a personal defense/tactical type, then shoot the match that way. What competition does besides adding stress, is give you measureable results to your progress. My line has always been " competition teaches me to think, with a gun in my hands". I also think competition makes you reach farther into yourself, than you would if you were alone.
If you want to win trophy's then play that way, get gamie, if thats your cup of tea.
If you want to be really accurate, then play that type of game, and do you want to be accurate offhand, in position or off the bench, there is a game for each.
I have one of those personalities that if I can't be really good, I don't want to play. Except for sporting clays, I don't suck, but I'm not competitive. I just don't want to put in the time and money to be great at that, but I do like the game.
My resume.
Started shooting competition in 1982, mainly to become a better what we call now, " tactical shooter"
Ipsc in the old days when we shot off ropes and ramps, from moving vehicles and over 12' high walls. We did weak hand draws, weak hand reloads, weak hand clearance drills that would make a modern day range officer have a coronary. We had hot ranges where your hand gun was loaded all the time you were there. This was truly Mecca, We were doing real world drills as a learning curve and I still have these skills today. This was the very practical side of Ipsc. Then it went gamie and I did not want to play, I wanted to be a marshal artist with a gun.
Metallic silhouette both small bore and large bore, AAA RATING IN BOTH. Great sport by the way, especially if shot with a normal handgun, you learn what your pistol is capable of, and how to adjust your sights and read the wind. I did shoot a TC Contender with rifle scopes to achieve AAA status, but as time went on, I liked shooting revolvers and .22 autos with irons for fun.
NRA action shooting, ( Bianchi Cup stuff ) Master rating although I never went to the cup, 2nd in state ( Texas ) and I really like that match. Not tactical but teaches you what you can do perfectly in a certain amount of time.
Steel plate speed shooting, How much fun. Our local club did not shoot Steel Challenge stages, but 2 different brands, one that shot out to 35 yard and the other that is up close and speedy.
Tactical and Personal protection matches that our local club puts on, more like IPDA but done much earlier and with higher penalties for over exposure to danger and not using cover.
NRA US service rifle, you have to use a rifle used by the US military in externally equal dimensions to the original. The best game in may opinion for learning how to really shoot, read the wind and mirage, learn your sight adjustments, sling positions and shooting positions. You truly are shooting against yourself. I have 8 points toward becoming distinguished, need 30.
NRA Bullseye, I don't shoot it enough, but have an expert rating.
Air pistol, International style, one handed 60 shot matches, Hard Hard game, teaches you follow through to the inth degree. rating sharpshooter, tough tough tough.
Bowling pin matches, only been to one, and got to shoot against Jerry Miculek, We were both very young, and he beat me.
Glock matches, been to at least 8, usually in the top 10, 1 year like 18th, my bad. Best 2nd with my model 21, my favorite.
Tactical shotgun, love it, just need a little time to go back and play.
3 gun, love it, just not enough time to play, and local stuff is 125 miles away.
Chevrolet team challenge, the most fun match I've ever been to, Did that for about 3 years in it's infancy, would like to do that again. When it's your turn, no time to BS, churn and burn.
USPSA, did it, I can't really talk about it, bad Mojo between me and my area directors as well as Sedro Wooley. If you like the game play it.
ICORE, revolvers are my favorite, shot it for about a year, and then my Mom got really sick, I did come in 3rd at the midwest regional shoot in Kansas, 1999. after that my Mom died and my work load became too much to play much. I am desperately trying to get back into it. I'm a much better person when I shoot.
Probably more, I'm a chief range officer certified by the national range officers institute. Have ro'd matches for over 25 years, I love shooting and all it has to offer. The one thing that I would like every one to know, is how many shooters prime out in their later years, 50+. I think it takes that long to overcome all the natural obstructions to shooting really well.
Now for the commercial.
If you want to be a really good shooter, practice and play in shooters games.
If you want to be a marshal artists, play the games your way, with the equipment, you want to be great with, and let the winning be secondary. A lot of my predecessors would come to plate matches and defense matches with their J frames and Sp101's or .380's just to shoot that pistol in competition with no hope of winning, but to get great practice.
I was a decalathon shooter for many years, I really did'nt care what I shot, as long as I shot. I helped me to become what I modestly call a good shooter. I've been out of the game for about 8 years, although I do compete occasionally. Now that I'm 50, I hope to reach my peak.